7 Increasing Node Count, Extending Reach

Creating prototype systems and making measurements becomes more expensive and time consuming as the number of nodes increases. Further variations, like experimenting with different BINs, requires even more combinations and measurements. A small number of good reliable measurements enables the creation of reliable modes that can then be used in simulation tools to create realistic results and enable comparison of various network configurations. Simulations based on models that match the previous results created jitter vs noise tolerance plots, which can be used to identify configurations that have the desired noise tolerance at reasonable jitter margins. These simulations are used to determine working topologies.

The simulations were used to analyze two different scenarios using Microchip’s LAN8670 with cable 2:
  • High node density - how many nodes can be supported in a given condition, and how close can they be spaced.
  • Maximum segment length - how long can a segment be, and how many (equally spaced) nodes can it support

High Node Density

When using a large number of nodes, an important parameter is how closely they can be to each other. The methods above were used to determine the minimum distance between nodes for a system, assuming a required noise tolerance of 200mV. If it is possible to avoid using a Common Mode Choke (CMC), minimum node spacing is 5 cm for up to 20 nodes, and 25 cm for up to 50 nodes. as shown in Table 7-1. More nodes may be possible with lower noise tolerance.

Table 7-1. Minimum Distance between Nodes without CMC
Number of NodesMinimum Distance between NodesTotal Length at Minimum Distance
85 cm35 cm
105 cm45 cm
205 cm95 cm
4025 cm9.75 m
5025 cm12.25 m

A Common Mode Choke (CMC) causes the node spacing to increase, as shown in Table 7-2.

Table 7-2. Minimum Distance between Nodes with CMC
Number of NodesMinimum Distance between NodesTotal Length at Minimum Distance
820 cm140 cm
1040 cm360 cm
2060 cm1140 cm
4080 cm3120 cm
5090 cm4410 cm

Maximum Segment Length

Maximum segment length, using the same configuration as above, is simpler. For 200mV noise tolerance, without a common mode choke, up to 50 nodes can support a total mixing segment length of 50 m. With a common choke, this drops to 45m.

If the end system can tolerate 100mV of noise, a 2 node system using cables 2 or 3 will function at a length of 100m. This has been shown working correctly under laboratory conditions.